The lack of definable leadership for last month’s EndSARS protest did not just make it difficult for the authorities to bribe or intimidate the inspirers of the protest, as some of the youths claimed on social media, it also made it possible for most of the youths to evade responsibility for the shortcomings of the protest.
One of those shortcomings was not knowing when to call off the protests, a failing that led to the violent subversion of the protests by sundry criminal elements and shadowy political figures with a grudge. In the end, according to police sources, some 73 people lost their lives, including 22 policemen, and scores of police stations burnt.
The cost to business is in excess of trillions of naira, with Lagos alone losing about a trillion. All this because the youths lacked the leadership and judgement to bring an otherwise excellent protest to a timely end. It would be strange to repeat that error when next they take to the streets.
But there is an error, perhaps even two, in the making already. The youths may lack the humility to apologise for letting their protests be hijacked and they bear direct and indirect responsibility whether they like it or not but they cannot claim that hindsight has not taught them a lesson or two about how to start a war and finish it. As they cross the uneven and uncertain divide between youth and the elderly, a line obfuscated by culture and arbitrariness, they must now persuade themselves to see virtue in moderation and find ways of developing the uncanny ability to judge complex and interconnected issues.
They must remind themselves about the peril of victory, especially a quick one delivered only a few days after kick-starting their protests, and the triumph of defeat, one alien to their campaigns. By now they must have sensed that victory and great triumphs do not mean noisy celebration but impose a far greater degree of responsibility.
The youths still proceed and speak as if no lessons have been learnt, or that the catastrophic consequences of their failings do not compel them to engage the future more cautiously and tentatively.
They isolate the concessions won from the government as if those concessions have no implications for the concessions not won. They have said and done nothing about the deployment of twisted social media narratives that told lies without compulsion, projected horrifying tales of abuse that were either unreal or exaggerations, and fanned stories clearly designed to achieve political goals and slander tribes and individuals. How would future protests be safeguarded from these manipulations? The same social media had been of tremendous help in exposing the horrors perpetrated by anti-robbery squads and regular policemen, sometimes even under the noses of their divisional police superiors. But by fighting an unregulated war, decentralizing protest leadership, and elongating and diffusing their demands, they unfortunately allowed a great campaign to be hijacked and bastardised, nearly to the point of watering down and diluting the achievements of the protest. Now, nothing is certain anymore beyond the threat of repeating the protest sometime in the future. But whether they will get converts like they attracted during the October protests, seeing that many children of the revolution also lost humongous sums to looters, is hard to say.
The youths are about to make another capital error. They seem prepared to veer into partisan politics instead of limiting themselves to activism connected with issues that transcend partisanship, tribe and religion. There is talk of setting up a political party, or organising youths to pressure political parties. Apart from the sentimental drivel about entrenching a dichotomy between youths and elders, an unwise and impracticable thing to do, including describing the elders as disgustingly acquiescent, the youths must become aware that they could never form a consensus against any party or coalesce to the last man around an ideology or platform. If the elders could not unite around a common platform, with some of the platforms distinctly ethnic or religious, why do youths think they could suddenly reach a consensus on platforms, candidates, and tangential issues like restructuring, rotation, presidentialism versus parliamentarianism, regionalism, etc.?
France’s Emmanuel Macron was not the product of a youth-led innovation in French politics. Nor was his movement, En Marche!, targeted against elders. It was both an ideological movement and a tantalising offer of newness away from the staidness of French politics. Besides, Mr Macron was a protégé of one of the dinosaurs of French politics, Jacques Chirac, and was a former minister who had been carefully groomed for leadership, including attending France’s highest policy institution, École nationale d’administration (National School of Public Administration) or Énarque. Mr Macron, a former member of the Socialist Party, was not a product of happenstance. Nor was his centrist movement, La République En Marche! (LREM), an arbitrary construct from a variegated French political milieu. Nigeria is unlikely to embrace any party simply because it is youth-led or designed to promote certain issues or even ideologies that resonate with youths. Instead, any youth bright enough to appreciate issues salient to Nigerian politics and society can enunciate his ideas and galvanise both young and old to create an unstoppable movement. Mr Macron did his own in about a year. It is not impossible to do it in two years in Nigeria, provided such a youth has the intellect and experience.
Promoters of the EndSARS protest will be unable to turn their activism into a movement, considering the baggage they have unhealthily allowed to bifurcate their action and pollute the protest’s essence and goals. They will need to look elsewhere.
A better option is to eschew their nonsensical romance with promoting a party for the sole aim of taking power anytime soon. Surely they can’t be so impressionable and incurably romantic to think they could unite and take on the elders.
Indeed, they give the impression that they are not properly grounded intellectually and emotionally to think that in a few months they could do what their phlegmatic elders could not do in more than 60 years. Instead of stumbling into politics which they are not prepared for, Nigerian youths, particularly in the EndSARS ‘movement’ should see the battle they started in 2017 and particularly on October 8, 2020 as an unfinished war.
There are too many unresolved issues with police and law enforcement reform that need special attention and concentration. EndSARS should be turned into a pressure group to monitor the reform and ensure it does not miscarry.
Already, given the backlash over the killing of some 22 policemen, and especially because there was no massacre at the Lekki tollgate, there are indications that the country’s reactionary law enforcement and security system appears minded to frustrate changes needed to foster better security and stability for the country. There is doubt that given the country’s present structure, a better law enforcement and security system can be engendered.
That doubt is justified. It will be hard to forge a workable police organisation and security system out of an unworkable political, social and economic patchwork. It won’t happen. So even before the youths began to be distracted, their original goal was endangered by the stultifying arrangement that has kept the country leprous and bedridden for decades. And without doing anything about Nigeria’s exploding population, the pressures of desertification, an extremely gross economic dependency system, and an overweight and futile system of government, the country as well as EndSARS activists will be fooling themselves.
In the midst of all this, it would be stupefying for the youths to think their modest and badly mismanaged EndSARS protest success can be quickly transformed into something enduring and remarkable. The rot goes far deeper, and is innately systemic and implacable. It is a monstrosity that requires years of single-minded focus, brilliance and occasional protests to undo. But it is also a campaign that cannot be successfully prosecuted by a leaderless pressure group probably already enticed by the allure of political power, probably insensitive to the demand of the times, and wary of taking responsibility.
End SARS#: Citizens Right Commission Commences Public hearing In Kogi.
End SARS#: Citizens Right Commission Commences Public hearing In Kogi.
Idris Ahmed, Lokoja.
Kogi state Public defender and citizens Right commission, has set up a special intervention committee to receive complaints, petitions and organise pubic hearing on human rights violations by the police especially the disbanded Special Anti Robbery Squad (SARS).
The public hearing which commenced on Tuesday at the Nigeria Bar Association hall, Lokoja, received 6 petitions, while 4 persons testified before the special committee.
A Lokoja based legal practitioner, Lawrence Ilogbuna told the committee how one of his clients Mallam Salaudeen Abdulhameed was arrested, March 18 2017, by SARS operatives in his house at Okehi in the central senatorial district of Kogi state, charged to court on the 20th and later granted bail same day.
He explained that SARS operatives re arrested Salaudeen same day bail was granted and took him back to Lokoja, where he was detained in one of the police cells for over two years.
According to the lawyer, the 3 bedroom flat belonging to his client was demolished by SARS without court order, while in detention under the supervision of the Administrator of Okehi local government area, Alhaji Abdulrahman Ohiare.
When cross examined on the offence of the petitioner, the lawyer disclosed that the suspect was accused of mischief by fire in connection with the burnt down police station at Okehi.
Barr Ilogbuna revealed that after several adjournments of the case, no mention was made and no trial until the report of the DPP from the ministry of justice was ready which exonerated the suspect of any link with the said violence and arson at Okehi.
Responding to the allegation, the head legal department of the police in Kogi state, denied involvement of police in the demolition of the suspect’s house at Okehi. She said the petition mentioned soldiers and not the police.
The police officer in charge of legal matters however, promised to get the case file and also reach out to all the officers alleged to be involved in the violation of human rights of citizens.
Other cases of alleged police brutality were also heard by the commission including that of one Mustapha Yusuf and his wife Fatima, who were alleged to have been taken away blindfolded by persons said to be dressed in SARS uniform.
Mr Jimoh momoh, father in-law of Mustapha narrated that SARS officers invaded the Agaminana area near FCE Okene and made away with his son in-law along side his wife with out any reason. He said the wife was released after 5 months in detention, while the husband is still with the police in Abuja.
The commission has adjourned hearing on the matter to Friday to enable the wife of Yusuf appear before it for more clarification.
Another case heard was the arrest of Suleiman Maryam by the men of SARS since 2017 and up till now his whereabout is not known.
Omoyole Toyin his sister told the commission that all efforts to locate him failed. She said members of the family and well wishers have combed police stations, hospitals mortuaries and correctional centres in the bid to know what happened to him with out success.
In another case, while others failed to see their loved ones, a victim of police brutality, Haruna Alhaji Edugbo from Ofu local government area of Kogi state was however successful as he was able to see his seized by the police. He told the commission that he bought a car and shortly after had an accident which resulted in serious injuries.
Edugbo said while he was bedridden, SARS operatives stormed his village Aloji in Ofu local government area and towed away his car. He said later the same team of SARS went and arrested his younger brother on an allegation of being in possession of a stolen vehicle.
According to the victim after thorough investigation,his younger brother was released, but the vehicle was not released since 2015 when it was towed away.
He disclosed that on his personal efforts, he discovered the car parked among many others seized by SARS and dumped at SARS base inside A division of the police in Lokoja.
All efforts to reclaim his car from the police division failed as he alleged that certain officers gave him conditions including giving them N200,000 before the car can be released to him.
The commission did not waste time and rushed to A division, where they met the DPO and the petitioner identified his car with relevant documents and particulars
Hearing on the matters continue on Friday March 2021.
#EndSARS: Old Women, Other Lead Protest, Says They March For The Children In Lagos
In what many described history seems to have resumed with full force in Lagos State on Thursday with protesters marching by Tejuosho Road in the Yaba area of the state.
According to reports, Old women and some young men brandished various placards in the area, defying the scorching heat to march for almost two hours.
They continued to chant, “End SARS and we march for our children.”
A number of them were also seen carrying the Nigerian flag in their hands, with microphones to make their voices audible.
The EndSARS movement, mostly peaceful, had turned to a blood field on Tuesday, October 20, when the personnel of the Nigerian Army went to the Lekki Tollgate area and opened fire on the crowds.
The soldiers from the 65 Battalion, Nigerian Army, Bonny Camp, Victoria Island, reportedly killed and injured several demonstrators.
A certain Lieutenant Colonel Bello, who was the Commanding Officer of the battalion, had reportedly led the soldiers to fire bullets at the scene. However, he claimed before the ongoing Lagos State Panel of Inquiry that he only fired blank ammunition into the air.
A day after the shootings, the Lagos State Governor had initially denied any loss of life from the gunfire or that he was aware of the deployment of soldiers.
Later, he admitted that two persons were killed in the incident, while the army said in a terse statement that the state government requested a military clampdown on the protesters to enforce its earlier-than-scheduled curfew.
FG Petitions CNN Over investigative Report On Lekki Shooting, Threatens Action
The Federal Government has written a petition to the US-based Cable News Network (CNN), demanding an immediate and exhaustive investigation into its report on the Lekki Tollgate shooting, to determine its authenticity and conformity to basic standards of journalism.
The government berated CNN for its investigative report on the #EndSARS protest in Lekki area of Lagos, pointing out that the media outfit breached the most basic of the core principles of journalism – balance and fairness.
In the petition written by the Minister for Information and Culture, Lai Mohammed, to Jonathan Hawkins, VP (Communications) in CNN Centre Atlanta, Georgia; the government said that if the international media organization does not carry out its demand, it will take any action within its laws to prevent CNN from making the #EndSARS crisis worse.
According to a report from Mouthpiece NGR, the government’s letter dated November 23, 2020, is titled “Re: How a bloody night of bullets quashed a young protest movement”.
The letter reads
News2 years ago
Kwara Gov Seeks Better Care For Fallen Heroes’ Families, Veterans
News1 year ago
Rape: Lady Caught Raping A 4 Year Old Boy In Rivers State
Grassroot1 year ago
Nasarawa: Appoint Isimbabi As Nasarawa SSG, Toto LG Youths Urges Gov Sule, Says Their Huge Electoral Strengths Should Be Consider.
Insecurity1 year ago
Egbira Development Association Nasarawa State Writes Gov Sule Over Banditry In Toto LGA
News2 years ago
Breaking: About 9 Gunmen Invaded Toto Town, Kidnappes Housewife, Husband Whereabout Unknown
News1 year ago
Gov. Bello Appoints New Personal Assistant, Sacks Security Aides
News1 year ago
Gov. Bello To Return All Local Government Administrators As Elected Chairmen
News2 years ago
Unknown Gunmen Attack Kogi Communities, Kill APC Chairman, Chief Imam and 20 Others, Injured Policemen